Two guys and one girl in a love triangle It’s a romantic plot we’ve seen dozens of time throughout cinema history. Even Hitchcock has done his own versions of it with films like Downhill and The Ring. He even took the story into a more sinister, less romantic direction—Blackmail, Shadow of a Doubt, Psycho. In his final silent film, The Manxman Hitchcock offers a fairly typical romantic melodrama, and yet the film is quite stylish and engrossing. The plot is a familiar one, seen in the first Best Picture Oscar winner Wings (1927) and through the 21st century in films like Pearl Harbor (2001). The Manxman, starring Anny Ondra, Carl Brisson, and Malcolm Keen, is based on the popular 1895 Hall Caine novel of the same name from, adapted for the screen by Eliot Stannard (one of eight screenplays he wrote for Hitchcock).
Pete (Brisson) and Philip (Keen) are best friends who live on the Island of Man. Pete is a poor fisherman, while Philip is being groomed to be a court magistrate. Pete and Philip are both in love with Kate (Ondra), who is very interested in Pete. Kate’s father Old Caesar (Randall Ayrton) disapproves of their plans to marry, citing that Pete is too poor. So Pete moves to Africa to get rich. Philip promises to look after Kate, who in turns falls in love with him. When news arrives that Pete has died, Philip and Kate consummate their love. But Pete turns out to be alive and returns as much in love with Kate as ever.
Alfred Hitchcock was not fond of this movie. Like so many of his early romantic dramas, he thought it wasn’t where his interest was. He even told Francois Truffaut that it was “banal.” While the movie won’t hold the interest of someone looking for a classic Hitchcock thriller, I found it to be a very visually inventive and passionately performed melodrama. The story itself might be predictable to some, though the three actors show conviction in their roles. I usually find it hard to engage with silent cinema, especially films that would work better as “talkies.” Much like Hitchcock’s The Ring, The Manxman is engaging thanks to its well-told story and strong actors.
There are many Hitchcockian touches; my favorite part of the film is Hitchcock showing Philip and Kate developing their romance through close-ups of her diary. At first, Kate calls Phillip “Mr. Christian,” but eventually she calls him by his first name. It’s a neat way to show the passage of time, and to emphasize that Kate is really falling in love with Phillip. It’s not just a childish flirtation like she had with Pete. The weight of their love story makes the following events more tragic. The film also features beautiful on-location shots of the island. Hitchcock juxtaposes those with the ugliness within the classism and hypocrisy within the town.
As Hitchcock left the silent era, he made a film that is interesting and dramatically compelling. The Manxman won’t quite entice all viewers but it does hold some interesting visual touches. The ending is surprisingly bittersweet. Hitchcock manages to keep the audience in the grey about who Kate should end up with. Neither fellow seems to even hear her, so when Kate makes her choice it is more solemn than romantic. The Manxman is a solid romantic drama, and it offers some pleasures for a Hitchcock aficionado. The film is currently streaming on FilmStruck.
Lukas provides a haunting look at Hooper’s masterpiece.
Bradley Cooper’s directorial debut starring Lady Gaga gets our recommendation.
Hitchcock ends one phase of his career with this, unfortunately unmemorable, film.
The movie involves a chorus girl, but the story behind the scenes is much more interesting.
This WWI-set espionage thriller has some similarities to a superhero blockbuster.
Our new horror column debuts with some Grade-A Nasty.
Murder and theatrics are on deck with a truly interesting early Hitchcock film.
Desiree Akhavan’s directorial debut is a charming and deceptively powerful look at culture and sexuality.
Don’t let the title confuse you, this is Hitchcock film that’s very much an “assignment film”.
Hitchcock’s early screwball comedy shows signs of his knack for visual humor.
The strong female characters and voices behind the camera are the highlight of this refreshing rom-com.
This Oscar-nominated Hitch thriller set its psychological game in the battlefield of a marriage.
This forgotten attempt at parody from Hitch should probably stay that way.
The latest “Fresh Eyes” examines Bigelow’s Oscar winning war film.
Hitchcock wasn’t too fond of this, his final silent film, but it still holds some of his trademark flourishes.
Showcasing this week’s best screenings in Austin, Texas.
Our “I Was Wrong” series returns with this second look at the action sequel.
Kelly Reichardt’s captivating and emotional story of a girl and her dog is this month’s pick.
Showcasing this week’s best screenings in Austin, Texas.
This Henry Fonda starrer is one of Hitch’s least stylish and most grounded works.
A close look at the power and importance of friendship in the Star Wars canon.
John Carpenter’s dystopian cult classic starring Kurt Russell gets profiled in the latest Fresh Eyes.
Sally Hawkins delivers an exceptional performance in this underrated biopic.
Manish takes a look at his favorite film and its meaning in the #MeToo era.
A look at Captain America and why his dedication and loyalty makes him one of the MCU’s best heroes.
Despite gorgeous cinematography and a strong performance from Ingrid Bergman, this is still lesser Hitch.
Nancy Savoca's romantic drama starring River Phoenix and Lilli Taylor is spotlighted.
This film from Hitchcock's silent era is one of the very first boxing pictures.
This is the (now streaming) greatest show!
Hitchcock's thrills lift up the nothing-special plot in this pre-war thriller.