Never Ignore a Man's Courtesy: Paul Thomas Anderson's Hard Eight
“This is a very fucked up situation.”
A heavyweight in the modern American cinematic landscape, director Paul Thomas Anderson got his breakthrough in early 1996, when his first full length feature premiered at the Sundance Film Festival to instant acclaim. Otherwise known by his preferred title Sydney, Hard Eight serves as PTA’s humble, low-key start before immediately making the transition to more elaborate productions like Boogie Nights and Magnolia.
Former mobster Sydney (Philip Baker Hall) meets the young unsuccessful gambler John (John C. Reilly) outside of a coffee shop, and takes him under his wing. This mentor-protege relationship between the two men becomes elevated and dangerous, as John goes on to not only win big, but cause trouble after wedding a hooker (Gwyneth Paltrow) and getting into a great deal of debt with a casino regular (Samuel L. Jackson).
A fairly straightforward story matched by its small production budget, Hard Eight works so well through the way it positions its central characters, as if they are rolling the dice at life itself, getting themselves into extremely risky situations, with next-to-no odds for getting bailed out when their good fortune fades.
The character of Sydney itself, reportedly spun off from the minor character Hall portrays in Midnight Run, is mesmerizing, as he comes across as the archetypal high roller with a lifetime of wisdom under his belt, who you’ll find in any casino. It would end up being Hall’s first high-profile, leading performance as well, and one that gave his career a major boost (in addition to planting the seed for his later collaborations with PTA).
Equally as impressive is John C. Reilly as John—a desperate guy motivated by what’s in his heart over his brains. Stuck in a bad situation from the start, as his plan to win big in Reno to pay for his mother’s funeral is a bust, he gets a major boost of confidence and cash via Sydney’s guidance. His desire leads into the film’s second major conflict, involving a large unpaid debt and a hostage situation that Sydney is forced to step in and assist with. It’s not hard to find some empathy for this down-on-his-luck loser, and Reilly, only 30 at the time, demonstrates how he would become one of this generation’s most prominent character actors with raw, impressive talent.
Hard Eight is a solid drama made doubly impressive by being a debut, as it feels like the work of someone with a lifetime of directorial experience. Those who are only catching up to this after seeing PTA’s more distinguished features may feel underwhelmed from a style/substance point-of-view, but Hard Eight’s power comes through the neo-noir sensibility that flows all the way through.
Interestingly, the impact of changing the title to Hard Eight and reflecting a more gambling-centric plot, made PTA think audiences would confuse it for a porno instead. In effect, this gave him the impetus for his sophomore feature, which you can look forward to reading about in the next installment of this series.
Side-note: the brief sequence involving PTA regular Philip Seymour Hoffman’s performance as an eager high roller is a must-watch, for any fan of the late actor.
The key to Dan Kwan and Daniel Scheinert’s two magnum opuses.
"Nothing comforts anxiety like a little nostalgia"
How the series ties everything from Bound to The Matrix Resurrections together.
The movies were back (mostly) in 2021 and Callie counts down her favorites, from Annette to Drive My Car!
How the novel by Tarantino lovingly opens up the world presented in the film.
Looking at some films that played at this year’s eclectic fest including Scenes from an Empty Church, Alien On Stage, and We’re All Going to the World’s Fair.
On how the new Netflix special is an effective look at an artist living through the pandemic.
On Martin Scorsese’s female characters and Vera Farmiga’s performance in his 2006 film.
A long, critical look at the greatness of the Saw franchise’s endings.
A personal essay on going back to the movies, and more.
On what the audience expects and what filmmakers deliver in two very distinct, yet similar, films.
The pseudo-major release of Tenet poses a myriad of complex questions about movie going in difficult times.
In her debut for our site, Sarah Fisher explores Jimmy Stewart’s career as he grew from “charming everyman” to Hitchcock’s vision of the “world-weary cynic”.
For his debut on the site, Loafpile dives deep into E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial and the current state of nostalgia-induced sequels.
Aaron looks at the powerful themes in The Last of Us - Part II in this deeply personal piece.
A first-hand experience of CFF’s all-virtual film fest.
The basketball drama from this past year sure did leave its mark.
Two decades later, Mary Harron’s adaptation remains a cutting dig at male masculinity.
A personal deep dive into why the character know as Kylo Ren is an important one.
Dave highlights the best of 2019 that weren’t in the Awards conversation.
From festival favorites to genuine surprises, Rachael highlights her favorite films of 2019.
Callie’s favorite films of the year illustrate just how bold and diverse a year for film 2019 was.
Ten spots weren’t enough for a year featuring films by Martin Scorsese, the Safdies, and Bong Joon-ho.